I can't call it the best books ever, because there are still plenty of great books I've not gotten around to reading.
This is in response to Dave's list, which can be read
here.
In alphabetical order:
American Psycho, Bret Easton Ellis
Laurel's notes: I love the 80s.
Why it is great: You could almost see this happening in real life. Who doesn't love this 80s?
Why you'll have a hard time with it: B.E.E. loves lists, you may not. Chainsaws and sex don't mix.
Why pick this over
Less than Zero? In that case, the movie was actually better than the book.
Me Talk Pretty Some Day, David Sedaris
Laurel's notes: can't talk, still laughing
Why it is great: The Easter story
Why you'll have a hard time with it: you won't
Why pick this over
Naked? even funnier
A Prayer for Owen Meany, John Irving
Laurel's notes: had a better story than
The World According to Garp, though
Garp had a better narrative.
Why it is great: the end is incredibly moving, YOU CAN HEAR OWEN IN YOUR HEAD WHEN HE SPEAKS
Why you'll have a hard time with it: I don't think anyone would have a hard time with this one.
Why pick this over
The Cider House Rules? They're both really good, but character development is slightly better in
Owen Meany.
The Secret History, Donna Tartt
Laurel's notes: the original art direction for the hardcover of this book was incredible.
Why it is great: a book can be a page-turner without catering to the lowest common denominator crowd (did you hear me, Dan Brown?)
Why you'll have a hard time with it: privileged college students in the Northeast are not especially sympathetic characters sometimes.
Why pick this over
The Little Friend? Donna Tartt's next book to come out took so long to finish that apparently the folks at Random House were afraid to edit it.
The Stand, Stephen King
Laurel's notes: the post-apocolyptic novel by which all other post-apocolyptic novels/TV shows are judged. Read the short version first if it's still in print, save the unabridged for later.
Why it's great: I don't know, but it is
Why you'll have a hard time with it: do you REALLY want to be seen picking up a Stephen King book that's not
The Dark Tower?
Why pick this over
The Dark Tower: it's all contained in one book as opposed to a series.
Why pick this over Cormac McCarthy's
The Road: not an Oprah pick
The Stranger, Albert Camus
Laurel's notes: I don't think you can consider yourself educated until you've read this. Is actually really easy to read in the original French.
Why it is great: seminal work of Existentialism but still a good story
Why you'll have a hard time with it: Existentialism is not exactly a cheery way of thinking
Why pick this over
No Exit? Good question. It's not like either is particularly lengthy.
The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle, Haruki Murakami
Laurel's notes: More people should read international fiction
Why it's great: This book has it all.
Why you'll have a hard time with it: you won't
Why pick this over something by Kenzaburo Oë? I don't know, I've never read him, though he did win the Nobel Prize for Literature